Skip to main content

Mathura Incident : Time to rethink or perish

Few days ago on 2th June 2016 two brave police officers , one SP city Mukul Dwivedi and one SHO Santosh Kumar Yadav ,lost their life as a result of unprovoked firing from miscreants during evacuation of jawahar park of Mathura and more than 20 miscreants died during vacuation due to various reasons. Unexpectedly Huge amount of arms and ammunition also been recovered after the evacuation.

After this incident people from all areas particularly media and politicians started giving their views on this particular incident. Almost everyone expressed their grief for the martyr policemen and their family and hailed their bravery. Also almost everyone questioned the functioning of police and their intelligence system , local administration, politicians who let the miscreants led by one ram vriksha yadav to occupy the park since more than two years. For all the above questions raised there will be a magisterial or probably judicial inquiry will be done along with probable CBI inquiry and may be we will reach to a certain conclusion.

Already many experts have written on this incident but I want you to look at this incident from a different perspective.Imagine a situation where police after getting proper intelligence input went to the spot with full preparation in order to evacuate the park. And as soon as they see the people sitting on trees with dangerous weapons they after giving warning fired on them as a result of which 3 person dies and others out of fear climb down and surrender and police after using required force evacuated the park. So the result no loss of life of from police side and less loss of life from miscreants side.

Though now it looks like perfect execution but a policeman will specualte and you all must be knowing somewhere that first reaction from media and politicians would have been that " police unnecessarily killed "innocent" people in order to evacuate one park. Complaints would have been sent by "NGOs" to all seniors officers, NHRC, SHRC, Women's commission , SC/ST commissions. And PIL would have been filed in High court and Supreme court by champions of human rights. Magisterial inquiry would have been started immediately, case would been registered with charges involving that of murder u/s 302 IPC and policemen involved in the operation would have been put under suspension either by seniors or under pressure from media , politicians , some commission or court till completion of inquiry. High probability of arrest of policemen involved in firing would have alsobe there.

It is this speculation which deter any police personnel from using any kind of force in law and order situations unless its absolutely necessary . The fear of going through mental torture of multiple inquiries and investigations have resulted in tendency of staying away from proactive use of force. The basic problem here is not of as per say inquiry the problem is multiplicity of inquiry by multiple agencies , commissions and courts. Even if one comes clean out of nine out of 10 inquiries the result of 10th inquiry will have same bearing on his life and career as any or all of previous nine would have. And further if he declared guilty in any of the inquiry media for surely pronounced him villain of highest degree.

Majority of policemen will agree with the fact that it is this mindset which is making police more and more defensive. This is also one of the reason of increasing number of policemen being killed by the criminals as a police personnel have to think many times before using his service weapon even to save his own life.In civilized society police should use force with utmost caution but that does not mean that police stops using power even where its needed out of fear of their career and life.

Multiplicity of institution is one of the sign of prismatic society where by no one is clear about his domain of power and responsibility and it will ultimately result in work paralysis.There is need to streamline the institution of inquiry.  Under police reform somewhere we also need to start thinking on this line and needs to categorically divide the work of various commissions and courts. If one complaint floats against a certain policeman to various forums there is need to make a system where its first gets decided about who will take up that complaint and accordingly inquiry should proceed.

Time has come to look into matters from police point of view as well and public movement have to be made to support the cause of policemen for which IPS officers have to take lead from the front otherwise soon we will see total lawlessness for which we our-self will be responsible.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

कर्ण और कृष्ण का संवाद - रामधारी सिंह 'दिनकर'

Following is excerpt from poem Rashmirathi written by Ram dhari singh dinkar. Karna reply to Krishna when he told story of his birth and ask him to join pandava side. सुन-सुन कर कर्ण अधीर हुआ, क्षण एक तनिक गंभीर हुआ,  फिर कहा "बड़ी यह माया है, जो कुछ आपने बताया है  दिनमणि से सुनकर वही कथा मैं भोग चुका हूँ ग्लानि व्यथा  मैं ध्यान जन्म का धरता हूँ, उन्मन यह सोचा करता हूँ,  कैसी होगी वह माँ कराल, निज तन से जो शिशु को निकाल  धाराओं में धर आती है, अथवा जीवित दफनाती है?  सेवती मास दस तक जिसको, पालती उदर में रख जिसको,  जीवन का अंश खिलाती है, अन्तर का रुधिर पिलाती है  आती फिर उसको फ़ेंक कहीं, नागिन होगी वह नारि नहीं  हे कृष्ण आप चुप ही रहिये, इस पर न अधिक कुछ भी कहिये  सुनना न चाहते तनिक श्रवण, जिस माँ ने मेरा किया जनन  वह नहीं नारि कुल्पाली थी, सर्पिणी परम विकराली थी  पत्थर समान उसका हिय था, सुत से समाज बढ़ कर प्रिय था  गोदी में आग लगा कर के, मेरा कुल-वंश छिपा कर के  दुश्मन का उसने काम किया, माताओं को बदनाम किया  माँ का पय भी न पीया मैंने, उलटे अभिशाप लिया मैंने  वह तो यशस्विनी बनी रह

एक पुलिसवाले की व्यथा

लोग अक्सर कहते हैं कि पुलिस सही तरीके से क्राइम कंट्रोल नहीं करती है लेकिन पुलिस करे तो करे क्या। उग्र भीड़ को क्राइम कंट्रोल करने पर आधारित एक लघु कथा। उन्मादी भीड़ हाथों में नंगी तलवारें, लाठी, डंडे लिए पागलों की तरह पुलिस वालों को पत्थर मार मार कर खदेड़ रही थी। उसकी पुलिस भीड़ से अपना असलाह और खुद को बचाते हुए पीछे हट रही थी। थानेदार का सर बुरी तरह फूट गया दो सिपाही उसे सँभालते हुए पीछे हट रहे थे बड़े अफसर, एस डी ऍम, सब मौके से गायब थे। ऑर्रडर देने वाला कोई दूर दूर तक नहीं था। भीड़ हावी होती जा रही थी। सब को कहीं न कही चोट लगी थी।भीड़ को लाठी डंडो से काबू करने के हालात तो बिलकुल भी नहीं थे। सबकी जान पर बनी हुई थी परंतु हाथ में लोड राइफल होते हुए भी जवान गोली चलाने से बच रहे थे, कैसी कायर स्तिथि थी। अचानक हवलदार बुधना को भीड़ ने पकड़ लिया और एक आदमी ने बुधना के सर पर कैरोसिन की गैलन उंडेल दी और दूसरे ने माचिस निकाली ही थी की धाँय की आवाज हुई और माचिस वाला जमीं पर लुढकने लगा।दूसरी आवाज में तेल के गैलन वाला जमीं पर कला बाजी खा रहा था । भीड़ जहां थी वहीँ थम गयी और उलटे पावँ भागने लगी लेकिन......अ

Scheme for creation of National Optical Fiber Network for Broadband connectivity of Panchayats

The Union Cabinet recently approved a scheme for creation of a National Optical Fiber Network (NOFN) for providing Broadband connectivity to Panchayats. The objective of the scheme is to extend the existing optical fiber network which is available up to district / block HQ’s level to the Gram Panchayat level initially by utilizing the Universal Service Obligation Fund (USOF). The cost of this initial phase of the NOFN scheme is likely to be about Rs.20,000 crore. A similar amount of investment is likely to be made by the private sector complementing the NOFN infrastructure while providing services to individual users. In economic terms, the benefits from the scheme are expected through additional employment, e-education, e-health, e-agriculture etc. and reduction in migration of rural population to urban areas. As per a study conducted by the World Bank, with every 10% increase in broadband penetration, there is an increase in GDP growth by 1.4%. NOFN will also facilitate implemen

Arnesh Kumar Judgement regarding arrest

Supreme Court on 2nd July ,2014 in Arnesh kumar vs State of Bihar(CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1277 OF 2014) gave following judgement regarding arrest in cases having punishment upto 7 years . In order to ensure that police officers do not arrest accused unnecessarily and Magistrate do not authorise detention casually and mechanically. In order to ensure court gave the following directions: (1) All the State Governments to instruct its police officers not to automatically arrest when a case under Section 498-A of the IPC is registered but to satisfy themselves about the necessity for arrest under the parameters laid down above flowing from Section 41, Cr.PC; (2) All police officers be provided with a check list containing specified sub-clauses under Section 41(1)(b)(ii);  (3) The police officer shall forward the check list duly filed and furnish the reasons and materials which necessitated the arrest, while forwarding/producing the accused before the Magistrate for further detention; 

नेताजी

" जो कुछ अच्छा हुआ , वह हमने किया , जो कुछ बुरा हुआ , वह किया अधिकारियों ने , यह सीधी बात नहीं समझती जनता , ख़ुद भी होती है परेशान , हमें भी करती है परेशान. कुछ मत देखो , कुछ मत सुनो , कुछ मत कहो , बस हमें वोट देते रहो "